PORTABLE ELECTRIC GENERATORS REVIEW:



RATINGS CHART, PRICE COMPARISON AND FEATURES
OF THE MODELS IN THE POWER RANGE 4,000-8,000 WATTS


Home | Standby | Portable | Backup Power | Discount generators |
Ratings: portable | Ratings: standby | Transfer switches | Solar power | Sizing | Generators

Portable generators

are intended to provide temporary power when utility is not available. They are usually connected to the loads via extension cords, although a connection via a transfer switch is more safe. Portables are often used in homes, small offices, on construction sites, farms, motor homes, recreation vehicles, and in camping trips. Most of the models are fueled from the on-board tank and therefore have short run time between refueling. More expensive multi-fuel devices can be hooked up to an external fuel source (such as natural gas or propane) for extended runtime. For more details, see Portable Generator Guide. To save your time and help you choose the best device for the job, we provided the chart below with the ratings and prices on some of the top rated brands followed by selection recommendations.
Last updated Jan 2010
MODEL
(with links
to spec,
price, reviews)
BRAND POWER
SURGE/
RUN,
WATTS
START FUEL TANK (gallons)
and
RUN
TIME
WHEEL KIT NOISE LEVEL DB (A) WHT
lbs
FUEL TYP.
ONLINE PRICE
OTHER FEATURES AND
EXTRAs
8000 TFG (165938) Northstar 8000/ 6600 gas; 7200/ 6200 LPG; 6400/ 5200 NG electric 6.5 gal
9 hrs
@ 50%
load
optional 74.5 277 tri-fuel: gasoline, LPG, natural
gas
$2000
Honda
OHV
engine
Elite Series
30242
Briggs & Stratton 8750/6200 recoil 7 gal
13 hrs @ 50% load
yes n/a 163 gasoline $1000
OHV engine
Elite Series 030241 Briggs & Stratton 8550/5550 recoil 7 gal
13 hrs @ 50% load
yes n/a 163 gasoline $780 OHV engine, battery charger
GEN8000B Blue Max 8000/5520 recoil 5.5 gal
9 hrs @ 50% load
optional 73 183 gasoline $700 OHV engine
PM0435003 Powermate Coleman 6250/5000 recoil 5 gal
11 hrs @ 50% load
yes n/a 152 gasoline $596 OHV Subaru;
similar to PM0545005
GEN
6000LHE #3293
Blue Max 6000/5000 electric 4.2 gal
12 hrs @ 50% load
yes n/a 233 diesel $1019 includes 12VDC
output
EU6500iSA Honda 6500/5500 recoil, electric 4.5gal
4.7 hrs @ rated load
yes 60 253 gasoline $3,600 inverter; speed control for fuel economy
5622 GP Series GP5000 Generac 6250/5000 recoil 6.6 gal
10 hrs @ 50% load
yes n/a 180 gasoline $700 OHV engine, low tone muffler
APG3560 All Power America 6000/5000 recoil, electric 11hr @ 50% load yes n/a 213 propane $1000 OHV engine, 12V outlet
TG52T42 Eastern Tools 6000/5250 recoil
11 hrs @ half load yes n/a n/a gasoline $520 GFCI, brushless alternator
GEN4000B Blue Max 4000/2800 recoil 3.96 gal
7.8 hrs @ 50% load
optional 67 60 gasoline $330 OHV engine, includes 12V output

SELECTION CONSIDERATIONS.

So, what portable generator is the best? Gasoline models are the most popular backup power devices, and many of them are relatively cheap. Several years ago Consumer Reports magazine in its reviews rated Generac model Wheelhouse™ 5500 1646 and Briggs & Stratton Elite series 30242 "best buys". Note however that their rating covered only a few brands, mainly those that are sold at hardware stores. Of course, if you need an emergency power immediately, a local store is your only option. Otherwise, buying online have a number of potential advantages: broader selection, lower prices, no sales tax in many cases, and often even a free delivery. For example, Blue Max 8000 with about the same power level costs about 30% less then Briggs & Stratton Elite model 30242. If you need to supply power to just a few small appliances or tools, consider contractor's GEN4000B that costs probably half of many comparable models on the US market. Among midsized units, the consumer magazine recommended Coleman PM0545005. Coleman sold its Powermate division to PRAMAC. This and some similar part numbers are no longer manufactured, but may still be available for sale quite cheap. By the way, the product manuals available at powermate.com still show old non-functional coleman's web address. Likewise, Troy-Bilt 30248 and 30245 are discontinued. Troy-Bilt is now a Briggs & Stratton brand sold at Lowe's at prices generally higher than you can get for comparable units online.

Note that with any gasoline-fueled portable model you will need to refill the fuel tank several times a day if you run it continuously at rated load. Unfortunately, unleaded gasoline has short shelf life and during a blackout gas pumps may not work. Therefore, a gasoline generator may be a good solution against short-term rolling blackouts or for camping trips. However, if you decided to keep a genset for a possible major emergency, you should store a large amount of stabilized gasoline (say, 100-200 gallons for a week supply) and replace it at least every other year.

Also note that most gasoline gensets use 3600-RPM air cooled engines with relatively short product lives: about 500-1500 hours of use. When used occasionally for emergency backup purposes, they may remain operational for about 5 to 7 years. But if you need a power source for frequent use (for example for job sites), consider a model with a diesel engine such as Blue Max 6000. Diesel generators cost more, but they have 2-3 times longer life then gas models. Diesel, like gasoline may not be available during a wide spread blackout, but it is more safe to store. If you are concerned about major blackouts, also consider propane models, such as APG3560. Propane can be stored practically indefinitely and it is the only type of fuel that is normally obtainable during power outages. When powered from a single BBQ tank, APG3560 will provide about the same run time as most comparable gas or diesel gensets per tankful.

Finally, if you prefer the convenience of portability and continuous power at extra cost, consider a multi-fuel device that can be hooked up to a natural gas line or a large propane tank. Among multi-fuel portables, the tri-fuel Northstar 8000 TFG was featured in a Consumer Reports and has good users reviews. You may just want to get an optional wheel kit. There are also Winco Tri Fuel models. Many gasoline models can be converted to multi-fuel generators with a third party conversion kit that enables them to run on propane and diesel. This would be less expensive then to buy a tri-fuel model, but you would still have to deal with a light duty gasoline engine.
For more information see our Review to Portable Generators and Consumer Reports introductory video on selecting the best emergency backup system.
NOTES:
The characteristics in the chart are based on manufacturer's or seller's specifications available at the time we compiled this review. The prices are given for the same period of time. We included the best advertised prices we found online at authorized dealers or other retailers (taxes and shipping are not included, but may be free). Of course, prices and specs are subject to change without notice. For the current deals on some of the top rated models as well as on permanent "whole house" backup power devices and transfer switches see our Discount Generators page.

All listed models provide standard outlets 120VAC 60 Hz (15 or 20 A) and a twist-lock 120/240VAC 30 A outlet (except for BlueMax GEN4000B, which has only 120VAC) . Other higher current twist-lock outlets if offered are listed in the "Features" column.
Weight is given without packaging (shipping weight will be higher).
N/a means "not available" (we could not find this information).
All data here are provided As Is- no responsibility for any errors. The devices compared above represent only a fraction of all available models. For official datasheets you may contact the respective manufacturers.
Product reviews and the analysis are provided for information purposes and reflects only the opinion of the author. The sole responsibility when selecting a product rests with the buyer. Also see this website's general Disclaimer and Terms of Use linked below.
CONTACT INFORMATION FIND ELECTRICAL GENERATORS BY SPEC BY USING THIS WEBSITE, YOU ARE AGREEING TO THE TERMS OF USE

© 2006,2008 L.Rozenblat